Together, we can push back against online abuse. Support the project ↗
ShieldHer
← All articles
ShieldHer Journal · Analysis

Why the term “revenge porn” is still useful, despite its flaws

A word can help people recognise abuse without capturing the full reality of it.

By GG19 March 202610 min read

In everyday conversation, it makes sense that people say “revenge porn”. The term is familiar and immediately understood, and it can quickly draw attention to an issue that is still poorly understood. But a word that helps people recognise abuse can fall short when it comes to understanding, classifying or tackling it. The strongest current approaches, from EIGE, European and French law, and practical tools such as StopNCII, already go beyond the “vengeful ex” scenario. They work with broader categories that also include threats, manipulated content and deepfakes.

Two ways of talking about the same issue

Start with a simple but decisive distinction. Different terms do different jobs. Some language offers a way into the subject and makes immediate sense to the public. More precise language helps people train staff, measure prevalence, classify incidents, moderate content, assess cases in court, write public policy, compile statistics and respond properly to the people affected.

This is where the debate often gets muddled. We expect a single term to raise public awareness, describe how the abuse works, identify what the law covers and guide prevention. That asks too much of it. “Revenge porn” still works reasonably well as a familiar entry point, but it works poorly as an institutional framework. The problem begins when we let the term do our thinking for us.

Why the term frames the issue too narrowly

Why? Because it frames the issue far too narrowly. “Revenge” implies a particular motive: retaliation. Specialists have pointed out for years that perpetrators may act for many reasons, including control, intimidation, humiliation, profit, voyeuristic gratification, social status, coercion or simply indifference to the person targeted. Many cases have nothing to do with revenge after a breakup. Focusing on that scenario creates an immediate blind spot. The word “porn” directs attention to the sexual or explicit nature of the material. The harm lies in the non-consensual use of an intimate or sexualised depiction. CCRI also points out that some victim-survivors feel the term trivialises or misrepresents what happened to them.

What the NCII framework helps us see

This is precisely why the NCII framework is more useful. I use NCII here as shorthand for non-consensual intimate image abuse: sharing, threats to share, manipulation, resharing and other non-consensual uses of intimate material. EIGE defines non-consensual intimate image abuse as the distribution, or threat of distribution, of intimate, private or manipulated images or videos by digital means without the consent of the person depicted. StopNCII explicitly includes manipulated images and deepfakes. This framework focuses on the absence of consent and loss of control, regardless of any assumed motive.

That shift changes what we see. When we stop asking “who is taking revenge on whom?”, we can finally see what the old story left out. We see threats to share material used to maintain control. We see sextortion, demands for money or more images, attempts to stop someone leaving a relationship, sharing in closed groups, screenshots, resharing by third parties, and circulation in channels where images become part of wider harassment. We also see what European and specialist frameworks now take seriously: manipulated content, convincing sexual fakes, deepfakes and edits intended to humiliate, blur the line between real and fake, or force victims to defend themselves in public.

Consent as the dividing line

Perhaps most importantly, this clarifies consent. Agreeing to an image being taken does not mean agreeing to its distribution. Sharing an image in an intimate setting does not give someone permission to keep it indefinitely, forward it, reshare it, publish it, alter it or exploit it later. French law already makes this very clear. Article 226-2-1 covers the distribution, without the person's agreement, of sexual images or words, even where they were originally obtained with express or presumed consent. Likewise, specialist frameworks for non-consensual distribution of intimate images (NDII) and NCII distinguish between how the material was obtained and its subsequent non-consensual use.

That distinction matters because it keeps the focus on the harmful use of the image. When the framing goes wrong, so do the questions. Why did the image exist? Why did you send it? Why did you trust that person? A better framing brings the real questions into view. Who crossed the boundary of consent, how did they do it, why, and who or what enabled them?

The law itself shows that revenge is far from the deciding factor, and that mass publication is not always required. French law goes beyond the stereotype of a viral post after a breakup. Article 226-2 also penalises keeping, using or disclosing to the public or to a third party certain recordings or documents obtained through an invasion of privacy. Article 226-2-1 covers sharing sexual images without agreement. Since 2024, Article 226-8-1 has covered sexual montages shared without consent. At EU level, Directive 2024/1385 addresses the non-consensual sharing of intimate or manipulated material, as well as threats to share it to coerce someone into doing, accepting or refraining from something. Recent law already works in terms of intimate or manipulated images, coercion and harm, moving beyond “revenge porn”.

Abuse rarely happens in isolation

This is also why we need to stop seeing these cases as isolated incidents. The idea of “one perpetrator, one victim, one post” is too simple. Abuse often spreads through a wider network. It can start with a threat before any image is shared. It can continue with an initial transmission and spread through comments, screenshots, re-indexing, archiving, reposting, collective mockery, use in a dispute or inclusion in a harassment campaign. EIGE stresses that online abuse forms part of a wider continuum of gender-based violence and unequal power. It extends real-world violence, with psychological, social, reputational, professional and sometimes physical effects.

Deepfakes put our categories to the test

Pornographic deepfakes make this impossible to ignore. They put our categories to the test. There may be no breakup, no former partner, no real event and no original intimate image. The harm can still be severe. The EU directive explicitly addresses producing and making available manipulated material that falsely depicts someone engaging in sexual activity. In 2024 French law created a specific offence for distributing sexual montages without consent. UN Women notes that AI is already amplifying online abuse, including through the creation of non-consensual sexual images. If a category falls apart as soon as the content is fake, it was already too narrow to describe the problem today.

There is also a political dimension. Every victim deserves to be taken seriously. European frameworks recognise that women and girls are disproportionately affected by the forms of violence covered by the directive, and EIGE places this abuse in the context of unequal power. Individual cases can differ. Treating these harms as isolated online misbehaviour overlooks the roles of social relations, control, coercion, reputation and gender hierarchies.

For victims, the term is far from neutral

The debate about words matters. For a victim, a term can offer the first recognition of what happened or the first distortion of it. Saying “revenge porn” may name the issue quickly, but it can also misname it. “Revenge” may imply that the target did something wrong to provoke the attack. “Porn” may place intimate images in a category that some victims do not identify with at all, and that they experience as minimising or misclassifying the abuse. Specialist organisations such as the Cyber Civil Rights Initiative identify both problems and note that some victim-survivors reject the term for those reasons.

That does not settle the question. A term can fit lived experience poorly and still offer a familiar way into the issue in public. That is the difficulty here. “Revenge porn” is still immediately recognisable to much of the public. That recognition continues to matter in practice. It helps people identify the abuse, find support and understand the basics even if they are unfamiliar with legal categories or specialist frameworks.

Context matters. For listening, support, training, research, institutional classification and public policy, more accurate terms such as NCII, non-consensual intimate image abuse or intimate image abuse are preferable. They describe what happened more accurately and avoid misclassifying abuse someone has already experienced. There is a simple principle here: a victim is not a concept to be corrected. If someone says “revenge porn” to describe what happened to them, a professional can start with their words and rephrase more precisely when doing so genuinely helps. In public communication, a familiar term can still make the issue visible and point people towards help, provided it is immediately broadened and never allowed to define the whole issue on its own.

The question is both whether the term is accurate and what would be lost if the issue suddenly became harder for the public to recognise. Precise language should make abuse easier to identify. Accessible language should reflect the experiences of the people affected. The balance is to accept that “revenge porn” can still offer a way into the subject, while using better language to listen to victims, train professionals, classify incidents and organise a response.

Start with familiar language, then broaden it

That is why policing vocabulary is the wrong approach. Sharply correcting everyone who says “revenge porn” would be a mistake. The better move is to translate between ways of speaking. Start with the familiar term, then broaden it. For example: “What people often call revenge porn is part of a wider pattern of non-consensual intimate image abuse.” That keeps the issue recognisable while restoring precision.

There is already a practical example of this shift. StopNCII.org is run by the Revenge Porn Helpline. An organisation can keep a familiar term in its historic name or on a public-facing page and still use the more precise NCII framework in practice, including for manipulated images and deepfakes. We can recognise the familiar term without letting it limit what we understand about the issue.

What the NCII framework changes in practice

This change of framework has tangible effects. It improves support by shifting attention from the existence of an image to its non-consensual use. It improves prevention by moving beyond defensive advice like “never send anything” and putting respect for consent at the centre. It gives us better categories by bringing sharing, threats, manipulation and amplification together. It also improves public action. When we misname an issue, we cannot count it, train people to address it or moderate it properly. As CCRI points out, protection from these abuses does not treat bodies or sexuality as shameful. It affirms that no one's body, image or intimacy can be used sexually without consent.

Conclusion

Saying “revenge porn” is not inherently wrong. It is still an effective way to raise awareness. It has become inadequate as a framework for analysis, law, prevention or public policy. In this case, the term offers a way into the issue but a poor guide to addressing it.

There is a tension we can no longer ignore. For victims, the term can feel inaccurate, painful or misleading. For the wider public, it is still a term many people immediately understand. We have to consider both its accuracy and what could be lost if the issue became less recognisable to the public. That is why treating the term as untouchable or banning it outright would both be mistakes.

The aim is to keep a familiar term from shrinking our understanding of the issue. For institutions, nonprofits, the media and anyone working to understand and address the problem, the approach should be clear. When useful, start with the term people recognise, then describe the issue more accurately and fully. The point is to move beyond “revenge porn”.

← Back to articlesShieldHer · The Journal